Bourbon Street Pizza (Plymouth)

Absolutely phenomenal pizza experience from start to finish! Bourbon Street Pizza sets the bar high when it comes to variety, flavor, and overall customer experience. The menu is impressively diverse — whether you’re a fan of classic combinations, gourmet toppings, vegetarian options, or bold specialty creations, there’s something for everyone. I was genuinely blown away by the number of choices, including customizable crusts, sauces, and toppings that let you build exactly what you’re craving. The TACO pizza is a MUST! The flavors? Outstanding. Every bite was perfectly balanced — rich, vibrant sauce, fresh toppings, generous cheese, and a crust that had that ideal combination of crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. You can taste the quality ingredients. Nothing felt rushed or generic; everything tasted thoughtfully crafted. Beyond the food, the experience was just as impressive. The staff was incredibly friendly, welcoming, and attentive without being overbearing. They were happy to answer questions, offer recommendations, and made the whole visit feel relaxed and enjoyable. You can tell they genuinely care about their customers. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, making it a great spot whether you’re dining with family, catching up with friends, or just grabbing a quick slice. Service was efficient, orders were accurate, and everything came out fresh and hot. If you’re looking for amazing pizza with tons of options and a team that truly values great customer service, this is the place. Five stars all the way — I’ll definitely be back!

- William Cochran -

I ordered a few large pizzas from here and they were absolutely delicious. Everything was fresh and tasted great. The store itself was very clean, and the staff were friendly, responsive, and welcoming. Overall, it was a great experience and I will definitely be coming back!

- Laurie Graber -

Being a boy mom I know my pizza and this place is top tier!! I know Doug & Krista will do great things with this place. Definitely going to be a regular bread stick junkie.

- Krystal Utt -

Loved this place! Stopped in while in Plymouth and thought we’d give it a try. Not only was the food fantastic but so was the service. Doug, the owner, was very kind and courteous. Would eat here again for sure!

- Christine Pullin -

This location is in great hands! New ownership has the staff focused on customer service and the food tasting great! This will for sure be one of my go-to’s for family pizza nights!

- Mark Comparato -

We have ate here the last 2 years we have come here for a golf trip. The food is great and the staff is nice. We will continue to eat here every year. Also love their old pictures on the wall.

- Steven Wallace -

Stopped here for a pizza while passing through. Staff was very polite and helpful. Has a seating area of around 6 booths but not the cleanest. Pizza was piping hot and tasty. Softer crust from conveyor over but trade off was it was out quick and we were starving. Has soda options but no alcohol which was a bummer. Overall probably the best pizza option for a sit down place in the area.

- Matthew Hiserodt -

Delicious sauce and great cheese. Would definitely order again!

- Elizabeth Zickgraf -